Annual Service…… Is it worthwhile?

  • XamSquishy's Avatar
    Ok….. don’t come at me for this, but….
    I have never booked any of my cars in for a service. None. Ever.
    I have been driving for almost 20 years and never done it. I think due it being optional rather than mandatory (like the MOT) I didn’t really bother with it.

    Now, however, I feel I’m in the minority! Everyone I know books their car in for an annual service.

    My question to you, oh wise ones, is….. Is it worthwhile paying for the annual service? All opinions and thoughts welcome :)
    Last edited by XamSquishy; 02-09-24 at 13:28. Reason: Grammar
  • 6 Replies

  • Best Answer

    Rolebama's Avatar
    Best Answer
    I am assuming that you have someone who does your oil changes, brake servicing etc.
    The MOT Test does not cover everything, and I always suggest having a service at the halfway point between MOTs, so the things that really matter get checked twice a year.
    Realistically, you need to have your brake fluid checked for water content and the effectiveness of your antifreeze checked every year, as one can be very expensive if it fails, and the other downright dangerous.
  • Drivingforfun's Avatar
    I'd be interested to know your car history

    Do you buy new cars and not keep them long?

    Or maybe the opposite - buy bangers and just drive them till they die?

    I can't really think of any other situation where I wouldn't service my cars, but interested to hear a bit more, I don't like the attitude of blindly doing something the way it's always been done... which maybe people do adopt to some extent when it comes to car maintenance
  • XamSquishy's Avatar
    So historically I’ve always had pretty aged cars and they’ve never cost *that much*…. Maybe this is why I haven’t bothered 🤔
    although the cars I’ve had always seem to last a lot longer than I ever expect them to! My friends and family cannot believe I don’t get a service haha!



    I'd be interested to know your car history

    Do you buy new cars and not keep them long?

    Or maybe the opposite - buy bangers and just drive them till they die?

    I can't really think of any other situation where I wouldn't service my cars, but interested to hear a bit more, I don't like the attitude of blindly doing something the way it's always been done... which maybe people do adopt to some extent when it comes to car maintenance
  • XamSquishy's Avatar
    this is a great point!
    I have no one who does all these things, I just put the car in for MOT every year and hope for the best. I guess the cost of a service has always put me off.
    you’ve convinced me, I’m going to get booked in asap. Your post has been really informative :)

    I am assuming that you have someone who does your oil changes, brake servicing etc.
    The MOT Test does not cover everything, and I always suggest having a service at the halfway point between MOTs, so the things that really matter get checked twice a year.
    Realistically, you need to have your brake fluid checked for water content and the effectiveness of your antifreeze checked every year, as one can be very expensive if it fails, and the other downright dangerous.
  • Noodles's Avatar
    Well I’ve been driving for over FORTY years and have never had a service on any of my cars. Some were old bangers in the beginning but once I started buying Beemers it just wasn’t necessary. I’ve heard so many nasty stories about customers being taken for a ride (excuse the pun) I decided to use my common sense and it’s saved me a fortune.
  • olduser's Avatar
    As Rolebama points out, there is no room for compromise with the braking system, it's a bit late to find out the brakes are not working at their best when you really need them.
    Brake fluid absorbs water. (it's hygroscopic)
    In normal use the brakes get very hot, therefore the brake fluid gets hot, if the fluid has water in it this can turn to steam, steam (a gas) stops hydraulics working.

    Suspension components have got lighter which makes them more easily damaged, suspension keeps the tyres aligned and on the road, so well worth having an experienced eye looking over them once a year.

    Engine service is related to use or miles but it is complicated.

    The oil is a package of chemicals, which deteriorate over time, the oily part will oxidise, the detergent gets spent (full of dirt), the buffer (neutralizes the acids from combustion) is used up.
    Water from combustion and unburned fuel accumulate in the oil, with modern engines steps are taken to try and get the oil hot enough to boil them off but if the engine never gets hot enough then they affect the lubricity of the oil.

    The oil filter, catches carbon from combustion and metal fragments worn off the moving parts.

    If a engine was started and never stopped it could cover a very high mileage without attention, because it gets up to temperature and stays there.

    An engine that doe's frequent stop starts (short journeys) suffers extra wear because each time it stops oil drains away from the lubricated surfaces, at next start lubrication will be marginal until the pump gets oil moving again, and the moving parts are designed to fit when the engine is at running temperature so when they are cool they are a bit loose.

    From the above we can see that there could be two different mileage intervals for engine service, a high mileage car will probably go past a year but a low mileage (stop start) could be less, the compromise then is to say 1 per year for both.

    Coolant, is usually water and antifreeze, the antifreeze also has rust inhibitor and I think most have a detergent, the rust inhibitor and detergent get used up over time but as water is added to the cooling system (topping up) the mixture gets diluted, at the annual service it should be checked and any overdilation corrected.
    I think, green antifreeze has an overall life of 3 years and long life (orange or yellow) 5 years.
    Should you have a car with waterless coolant the coolant has a life of 10 years' (NEVER TOP IT UP WITH WATER)


    I hope that helps.