EVs causing all insurance to increase

  • Drivingforfun's Avatar
    I was chatting to a couple of friends of family who are older but not elderly. No claims for either of them since age 17, responsible drivers, low risk jobs, both have fairly average small low powered 1.0L cars.

    Both renewed insurance last month and both policies went up by around £100 - even after shopping about.

    Apparently it is to do with EVs with most being written off rather than repaired, coupled with the fact that they are more expensive to buy.

    Apparently last year insurance companies paid out £1.11 for every £1 they took in.

    So insurance is going up for ICE cars as well…as even if one doesn’t drive an EV they have to price in the fact that the chance of you having an at-fault crash with one is going up every day.

    Not sure whether to believe or not, as stated on another thread an insurance company tried to tell me that a 2% rise in tax was the reason for a 40% increase in premium.

    But makes a bit of sense to me.

    Has anyone heard similar?
    Last edited by Drivingforfun; 20-12-23 at 10:42. Reason: more info
  • 4 Replies

  • Marc's Avatar
    Community Manager
    Interesting @Drivingforfun I've not heard this. And I expect to put it to the test soon when I finally get a new car.
    I had assumed that increases are part of 'cost of living' in that everything is more expensive these days due to inflation.
    I suppose inflation within the car insurance industry has to have a cause, though?
    Welcome to the RAC Community! Start here 😀
    You can say hi and introduce yourself too 👋
    What should you do after a collision? 🤔
    Got a question or want to start a discussion? Create a new post here. ✍
    Looking for info? Start with a new search. 🔍
  • NMNeil's Avatar
    Perhaps it's due to how EV's are made.
    https://insideevs.com/news/673158/te...es-mainstream/
    It may be good from a manufacturing standpoint but if you have anything other than minor damage to a body panel it's not just a case of the local body shop beating out the frame damage or cutting out the damaged section and fitting a new piece, you now have to replace a very large, and undoubtedly very expensive casting, making it uneconomic, hence easily written off.
  • Rolebama's Avatar
    Just received my renewal. They very kindly showed my last (current) premium of £237.84. They are asking for a renewal premium of £438.18. Complete with a load of nonsense about global increases and inflation in an attempt to justify a near 100% increase. Just how stupid do insurers think we are?
  • Marc's Avatar
    Community Manager
    Just received my renewal. They very kindly showed my last (current) premium of £237.84. They are asking for a renewal premium of £438.18. Complete with a load of nonsense about global increases and inflation in an attempt to justify a near 100% increase. Just how stupid do insurers think we are?

    Wow, not good @Rolebama
    I had a similar experience the other day. Approx £240 last year and they wanted £600+ this time.
    So I went to a price comparison website and got a good deal with a respected and long-established organisation.
    I think they sell a certain number via the price comparison sites and pull their offers once all have been taken. Then come back with new offers. So well worth checking them.